Don't Take Our Word for It — Read Theirs
Real clients. Real coverage. Real feedback from people across central Indiana who made the switch and never looked back.
What Our Clients Are Saying
We've been serving Kokomo and central Indiana since 2006, and our clients tend to be pretty vocal about their experience. The reviews below come directly from our Google Business Profile — unfiltered, unedited, and from verified clients.
A Few That Say It Better Than We Could
These three reviews stood out — not because we picked the nicest ones, but because they speak to what matters most: real service, real follow-through, and what it feels like to actually work with us.
What Clients Say About Each Type of Coverage
Not every insurance experience is the same. Here's how clients describe working with us across the coverage types we handle most.
Choosing auto insurance can be difficult when coverage limits, deductibles, and carrier options vary widely. Comparing multiple insurance companies through one agency helps you find protection that fits both your vehicle and your budget.
Home and Auto
Clients who bundled their home and auto coverage with us consistently mention the savings they found after we compared rates across our carrier network — and how straightforward the process was.
Claims Experience
This is the one that matters most. Anyone can sell you a policy. The real test is what happens when you need to use it.
Customer Service
No hold times. A real person on the phone. Clients notice — and they mention it.
Had a Good Experience? We'd Love to Hear from You
If you're a current client and we've taken care of you — whether it was at renewal, during a claim, or just on a call when you had a question — leaving us a review makes a real difference. It helps other families in Kokomo and central Indiana find an agency they can trust.
It takes less than two minutes, and we genuinely appreciate it.
Common Questions About Our Agency
Is Your Choice Insurance a local agency or a national chain?
We're locally owned and operated out of Kokomo, Indiana. Sara Pyle-Pearce founded the agency in 2006, and we've been fully independent since January 2022. You're working with people who live and work in the same community you do.
What makes Your Choice Insurance different from other agents in Kokomo?
We're an independent agency, which means we work with around 40 different carriers to find you competitive coverage — not just one company's options. And when you call us, a real person answers. No hold music, no automated menus.
How does Your Choice Insurance handle claims?
We help you navigate the process from the first call. We'll connect you with your carrier's claims team and stay available to answer questions along the way. Several of our Google reviews speak specifically to the claims experience — we'd encourage you to read through them.
Is Your Choice Insurance any good for home and auto coverage in Kokomo?
We cover homeowners and auto insurance across Kokomo and central Indiana, and bundling both is one of the most common ways our clients save money. The reviews on this page reflect a range of clients and coverage types — that's the most honest answer we can give.
Can I trust the reviews on this page?
Every review on this page is pulled directly from our Google Business Profile. We don't curate or edit them. What you see is what our clients wrote.
Thinking About Switching? Here's What Others Found
A lot of our clients came to us after feeling ignored by a bigger agency or frustrated by a call center that couldn't give them a straight answer. They weren't sure switching was worth the hassle. Then they called us.
If you're in that same place right now, the reviews on this page are the honest answer to your question. Read through them, then reach out when you're ready.
